Intercollegiate Athletics: Recent Trends in Teams and Participants in National Collegiate Athletic Association Sports (12-JUL-07, GAO-07-535). Since the 1970s, the roles of women as both students and athletes have changed in higher education, with female enrollment surpassing male enrollment, and female athletic participation showing gains as well. These changes have generated public interest in whether women participate in athletics at comparable levels to men and whether men's opportunities have decreased as a result of the increased opportunities for women. Under the Comptroller General's authority, GAO assessed the extent to which the numbers of men's and women's intercollegiate sports teams and participants at 4-year colleges have changed from the 1991-1992 through 2004-2005 school years. -------------------------Indexing Terms------------------------- REPORTNUM: GAO-07-535 ACCNO: A72550 TITLE: Intercollegiate Athletics: Recent Trends in Teams and Participants in National Collegiate Athletic Association Sports DATE: 07/12/2007 SUBJECT: College students Colleges and universities Comparative analysis Internal controls Sports Statistical data Women ****************************************************************** ** This file contains an ASCII representation of the text of a ** ** GAO Product. ** ** ** ** No attempt has been made to display graphic images, although ** ** figure captions are reproduced. Tables are included, but ** ** may not resemble those in the printed version. ** ** ** ** Please see the PDF (Portable Document Format) file, when ** ** available, for a complete electronic file of the printed ** ** document's contents. ** ** ** ****************************************************************** GAO-07-535 * [1]NCAA OpenGroup Athletic Data * [2]NCAA ClosedGroup Athletic Data * [3]SportbySport Analyses * [4]Department of Education Enrollment Data * [5]GAO Contact * [6]Staff Acknowledgments * [7]GAO's Mission * [8]Obtaining Copies of GAO Reports and Testimony * [9]Order by Mail or Phone * [10]To Report Fraud, Waste, and Abuse in Federal Programs * [11]Congressional Relations * [12]Public Affairs Report to Congressional Addressees United States Government Accountability Office GAO July 2007 INTERCOLLEGIATEATHLETICS Recent Trends in Teams and Participants in National Collegiate Athletic Association Sports GAO-07-535 Contents Letter 1 Appendix I Briefing Slides 5 Appendix II Scope and Methodology 26 NCAA Open-Group Athletic Data 29 NCAA Closed-Group Athletic Data 30 Sport-by-Sport Analyses 31 Department of Education Enrollment Data 33 Appendix III Schools Included in the Open Group 35 Appendix IV Schools Included in the Closed Group 50 Appendix V Comments from the Department of Education 61 Appendix VI GAO Contact and Staff Acknowledgments 63 Related GAO Products 64 Tables Table 1: Availability of Team and Participant Data from Various Sources 29 Table 2: Sports Included in the NCAA Report and Analyzed for This Report 33 Table 3: Open-Group Schools (state abbreviation) 35 Table 4: Closed-Group Schools (state abbreviation) 50 Abbreviations A & M Agricultural and Mechanical A & T Agricultural and Technical CUNY (The) City University of New York EADA Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act Education Department of Education IPEDS Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System NAIA National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics NCAA National Collegiate Athletic Association NCCAA National Christian College Athletic Association NCES National Center for Education Statistics NFHS National Federation of State High School Associations NJCAA National Junior College Athletic Association SUNY (The) State University of New York USCAA United States Collegiate Athletic Association This is a work of the U.S. government and is not subject to copyright protection in the United States. It may be reproduced and distributed in its entirety without further permission from GAO. However, because this work may contain copyrighted images or other material, permission from the copyright holder may be necessary if you wish to reproduce this material separately. United States Government Accountability Office Washington, DC 20548 July 12, 2007 The Honorable Edward M. Kennedy Chairman The Honorable Michael B. Enzi Ranking Member Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions United States Senate The Honorable Joseph I. Lieberman Chairman Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs United States Senate The Honorable George Miller Chairman The Honorable Howard P. "Buck" McKeon Ranking Member Committee on Education and Labor House of Representatives The Honorable Patty Murray United States Senate Since the 1970s, the roles of women as both students and athletes at colleges and universities have changed significantly. In particular, women's undergraduate enrollment has increased more than twice as fast as men's since 1970, and, by 1978, female enrollment surpassed male enrollment for the first time. During this same time period, women's opportunities in college athletics have increased as well, both in terms of the number of female participants and the number of women's teams. Since the 1970s, the roles of women as both students and athletes at colleges and universities have changed significantly. In particular, women's undergraduate enrollment has increased more than twice as fast as men's since 1970, and, by 1978, female enrollment surpassed male enrollment for the first time. During this same time period, women's opportunities in college athletics have increased as well, both in terms of the number of female participants and the number of women's teams. These changes have generated public interest in whether women participate in athletics at comparable levels to men and whether men's opportunities have decreased as a result of increased opportunities for women. To explore these issues, we addressed the following two questions under the Comptroller General's authority: These changes have generated public interest in whether women participate in athletics at comparable levels to men and whether men's opportunities have decreased as a result of increased opportunities for women. To explore these issues, we addressed the following two questions under the Comptroller General's authority: o To what extent have the numbers of men's and women's intercollegiate sports teams at 4-year schools changed in recent years? o To what extent have the numbers of men's and women's intercollegiate sports teams at 4-year schools changed in recent years? o To what extent have the numbers of male and female participants in intercollegiate sports at 4-year schools changed in recent years? During the week of March 26-30, 2007, we briefed interested congressional staff on the results of our study, and this report formally conveys information provided during those briefings. In general, we found that women exhibited greater gains than men in athletic opportunities from the 1991-1992 to 2004-2005 school years. More specifically, we found that: o The number of women's teams showed large increases over the period and surpassed the number of men's teams by the mid-to-late 1990s. For example, the number of women's golf, lacrosse, and soccer teams more than doubled from 1991-1992 to 2004-2005. The overall number of men's teams showed more modest increases, with the number of wrestling teams actually decreasing over the period. o The numbers of both male and female participants steadily increased from 1991-1992 to 2004-2005. Female participants did show larger rates of increase, but men's participation levels were greater than women's, both in absolute terms and relative to their respective enrollments, throughout this time period. Female participation increased from 1991-1992 levels more than female enrollment, whereas male participation increased at rates similar to male enrollment. However, at the school level, overall athletic participation rates were significantly^1 greater for men in at least three out of four coed colleges and universities from 1991-1992 to 2004-2005. To determine these changes in the numbers of teams and participants at 4-year schools, we obtained athletic data from the National Collegiate Athletics Association (NCAA)^2--the largest athletic association in the U.S.--for two groups of colleges and universities: o Open Group--This group includes the entire NCAA membership, which increased from 847 schools in 1991-1992 to 1,045 schools in 2004-2005. Data for this group were obtained from the NCAA's published reports on sports sponsorship and participation. Trends observed for this group may reflect both school-level decisions to add, drop, expand, or contract teams and changes in NCAA membership. o Closed Group--This group includes the 750 colleges and universities that were consistent members of the NCAA throughout the time period^3 and that consistently reported team and participant information in each year. Data for this group were customized by the NCAA for this report. Trends observed for this group reflect school-level decisions only. ^1 "Significantly" designates 5 percentage points or greater. ^2 We used NCAA data because they were the only viable option for analyzing annual athletic trends for teams and participants over an extended period. For our report, we examined all 27 NCAA sports that were consistently reported throughout the time period, and we reviewed full-time undergraduate enrollment data from the Department of Education for both groups of schools to understand the context for the athletic trends.^4 To determine the reliability of the athletic data, we interviewed NCAA officials, assessed the process by which the data were collected, performed internal consistency checks, examined year-to-year fluctuations, and compared equivalent items across the open and closed groups. To assess the reliability of enrollment data, we reviewed a data reliability study conducted by the department and performed internal quality control checks on the enrollment data. Through this process, we determined that both the athletic and enrollment data we used were reliable for the purposes of this report. For additional information on our study review, please see appendix II. For additional results of our analysis by sport, please see GAO-07-744SP.^5 We conducted our work from December 2005 to June 2007 in accordance with generally accepted government auditing standards. This study focused on recent team and participant trends in intercollegiate sports for both men and women.^6 We did not assess the extent to which these trends may be caused or affected by external factors--such as gender-equity concerns, budget fluctuations, changes in high school and college student populations, or the popularity of any one sport--because this was beyond the scope of our work. In addition, available data did not allow us to assess the causal relationship between athletic trends and these external factors. ^3These schools were not members of the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA). ^4Schools in our study varied in the number of NCAA sports they sponsored. ^5GAO, Intercollegiate Athletics: Trends by Sport in National Collegiate Athletic Association Sports, [13]GAO-07-744SP (Washington, D.C.: June 2007). ^6This report measures trends in teams and participants in intercollegiate athletics. In contrast, the Department of Education has separate standards it uses to determine whether institutions of higher education provide equal athletic opportunity for members of both sexes pursuant to Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 (20 U.S.C. SS1681-88). This report does not address--and is not intended to address--compliance with federal laws or regulations. We provided a draft of this report to officials of the U.S. Department of Education for review and comment, and also for technical review. In written comments on our draft report, Education did not explicitly agree or disagree with our findings, but did highlight our finding that men had greater overall participation levels than women throughout our study period, both in absolute terms and relative to their respective enrollments. Education also recommended that we include a footnote clarifying that the measures used in this report are distinct from the department's standards for assessing compliance with federal laws, and we included footnote 6 above. Education further explained that it measures whether equal athletic opportunities are provided to men and women based on the number of athletic participants, but not the number of teams sponsored. In particular, Education said that one of the measures the department uses to assess a school's compliance with federal laws is whether the percent of male and female athletes at the school is "substantially proportionate" to the percent of male and female students enrolled in the school. Education's written comments appear in appendix V. We also incorporated Education's technical comments, where appropriate. Because they are technical and not substantive in nature, they are not published in this report. We also provided a draft of this report to NCAA officials for technical review and incorporated their technical comments, where appropriate. We are sending copies of this report to relevant congressional committees and other interested parties and will make copies available to others upon request. In addition, this report will be available at no charge on GAO's Web site at [14]http://www.gao.gov . If you or your staff has any questions about this report, please contact me at (202) 512-7215 or [15][email protected] . Contact points for our Offices of Congressional Relations and Public Affairs may be found on the last page of this report. Other major contributors to this report are listed in appendix VI. George A. Scott Director, Education, Workforce, and Income Security Issues Appendix I: Briefing Slides Appendix II: Scope and Methodology To determine the recent trends in teams and participants in intercollegiate athletics, we analyzed athletic data from the National Collegiate Athletics Association (NCAA) and enrollment data from the department of Education (Education) for two groups of colleges and universities: o Open Group--This group includes the entire NCAA membership, which increased from 847 schools in the 1991-1992 school year to 1,045 schools in the 2004-2005 school year. Observed trends for this group will reflect both school-level sports sponsorship decisions and changes in NCAA membership. The primary source of athletic data for this group was the NCAA's 1981-82 to 2004-05 Sports Sponsorship and Participation Rates Report, which is available from the NCAA Web site ( [16]http://www2.ncaa.org/portal/media_and_events/ncaa_publications/research ). Data from this publication were modified for the purposes of this report via correspondence with NCAA officials, as discussed below. The source of aggregate enrollment data for this group was Education's Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) Peer Analysis System, also available on the Internet ( [17]http://nces.ed.gov/ipedspas ). See appendix III for the list of schools that were included in the open group at any time during the study period. o Closed Group--This group includes the fixed group of 750 colleges and universities that were consistent members of the NCAA throughout the time period, that were not members of the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA) at any time during the time period,^1 and that reported team and participant information in each year of our time period. The NCAA analyzed its internal school-level data and provided us customized team and participant aggregate statistics for use in this report, as discussed hereafter. The source of enrollment data for this group was also Education's IPEDS Peer Analysis System. For the school-level comparison between athletic participation and enrollment, we provided the NCAA school-level enrollment data for its members from IPEDS, and the NCAA used these data in concert with its school-level athletic data to generate the results of this comparison. See appendix IV for the list of 750 schools that were included in the closed group. ^1The NAIA is the second-largest national intercollegiate association in the United States. We eliminated colleges and universities that were joint members of the NCAA and NAIA to reduce the possibility of schools not having reported complete information to the NCAA. Annual athletic data for the open group are available from the NCAA for the 1981-1982 through 2004-2005 school years, but data for the closed group are available only for the 1991-1992 through 2004-2005 school years. Thus, the focus of this report is on the 1991-1992 through 2004-2005 period. For both groups, total participant counts reflect the sum of the number of individuals participating in each of the individual sports that were consistently reported throughout the time period. To the extent that some athletes participated on more than one team, the number of participants may be overstated. Enrollment data are available from Education from the 1991-1992 through 1998-1999 and 2000-2001 through 2004-2005 school years; data for the 1999-2000 school year for aggregate analysis have not been publicly released, and Education has no plans to release such data in the future.^2 As a result, enrollment data for this school year were omitted from the aggregate comparisons between athletic participation and enrollment provided on slides 19 and 20 of appendix I. However, school-level data for school-level analysis are available for 1999-2000, so this year was included for schools reporting enrollment data for the school-level comparison provided on slide 21 of appendix I. We interviewed NCAA officials and performed internal quality control checks on both the athletic and enrollment data and determined that these data were reliable for the purposes of this report. We conducted our work from December 2005 to June 2007 in accordance with generally accepted government auditing standards. We did not assess the extent to which these trends may be caused or affected by external factors--such as gender-equity concerns, budget fluctuations, changes in high school and college student populations, or the popularity of any one sport--because this was beyond the scope of our work. However, in 2001 we presented reasons self-reported by school administrators for why teams were added and dropped.^3 Also, the introduction to the NCAA sports sponsorship and participation report presents several other potentially influential factors as well. ^2Officials from Education note that the agency did not complete reliability testing of data for the 1999-2000 school year because reporting rates were particularly low for this year. Please see the associated discussion in "Department of Education Enrollment Data" below. ^3For more information, see GAO, Intercollegiate Athletics: Four-Year Colleges' Experiences Adding and Discontinuing Teams, [18]GAO-01-297 (Washington, D.C.: March 8, 2001). For this report, we examined the possibility of using data from the other national athletic associations--including the NAIA, the National Christian College Athletic Association (NCCAA), the National Junior College Athletic Association (NJCAA), and the United States Collegiate Athletic Association (USCAA)--as well as individual athletic conferences (e.g., Big Ten Conference), institutions of higher education, the National Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS), and state governing organizations for high schools. We found that nationally representative team and participant annual data are not systematically available at either the college or high school level for before the 2000-2001 school year.^4 Education now collects and stores athletic team and participant data via the Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act (EADA), but Education does not have these data for before the 2000-2001 school year. Furthermore, Education officials expressed some concerns about the reliability of EADA data.^5 Thus, we determined that the NCAA data were the only viable option for analyzing annual athletic trends for teams and participants for both open and closed groups of colleges and universities over an extended period. ^4 The EADA generally requires institutions of higher education to annually collect and make publicly available team, participant, and other athletic data for the immediately preceding school year starting in October 1996 for the 1995-1996 school year. However, the EADA does not require institutions to retain those data for subsequent years. ^5 For example, the definition of "reporting year" has varied from school to school, with some schools reporting over an 8 month period, and other schools reporting over different 12 month periods. Education noted that the very first year of data collection (2000-2001) was particularly problematic because submissions varied dramatically from school to school and for other reasons. Table 1: Availability of Team and Participant Data from Various Sources Availability of information, by source Information Athletic required Schools Conferences associations Education Number of men's Media guides Annual NCAA: NAIA: 1991-1992 EADA data and women's reports NCCAA:USCAA - present for sports teams, by (data quality for all NJCAA: 2000-2001 school may vary by years NFHS: - present 2000-2001 year and by Not - present gender) available 2004-2005 EADA records - present 2004-2005 - present Not available Numbers of men Media guides Not NCAA: NAIA: 1991-1992 EADA data and women and squad available NCCAA:USCAA - present for participating in lists NJCAA: 2000-2001 school sports, NFHS: - present 2000-2001 by school (data quality Not - present may vary by available year and by 2004-2005 gender) - present 2004-2005 EADA records - present Not available Men's and Not available Not NCAA: NAIA: 1981-1982 EADA data women's sports available NCCAA:USCAA - present for teams and NJCAA: Unknown participants, in NFHS: 1994-1995 2000-2001 aggregate - present - present 2001-2002 - present 2000-2001 - present 1971-1972 - present Source: GAO interviews with school, conference, association, and Education officials. NCAA Open-Group Athletic Data The NCAA's 1981-82 to 2004-05 Sports Sponsorship and Participation Rates Report provides annual data on the number of teams sponsored and the number of participants by sport and in aggregate for all men's (27) and women's (27) sports sponsored by the NCAA. Please see this original report for variable definitions and factors influencing historical trends, such as changes in data collection procedures that occurred between 1981-1982 and 2004-2005. This NCAA report is based on reports provided by schools to the NCAA each year,^6 and the NCAA uses these school reports to help manage its sports championships, scholarships, and divisional championship realignment. We used the team and participant data directly from the NCAA report. ^6 For school years 1991-1992 through 1994-1995 and 1999-2000 through 2004-2005, the report uses annual NCAA membership reports provided by schools. For school years 1995-1996 through 1998-1999, the report is based on athletic records collected by schools to meet the requirements of the EADA. Because the NCAA membership has changed annually, changes in the aggregate figures for the NCAA may reflect both school-level decisions to add, drop, expand, or contract teams and the changing membership itself. We modified some data presented in the tables of the NCAA report to resolve apparent inconsistencies and unexplained fluctuations of those published data. With regard to consistency, we compared aggregate figures for each sport to the sum of disaggregated figures for the corresponding sports. Where internal inconsistency or large and unexplained fluctuations (e.g., apparent numerical typographical errors) were found, we determined, in concert with NCAA officials, whether and how to correct those data to resolve those inconsistencies. With regard to fluctuations, we examined year-to-year fluctuations in the athletic data for each sport and in aggregate. Where large and unexplained fluctuations were found--such as with the case of apparent numerical/typographical errors--we determined, in concert with NCAA officials, whether and how to correct those data as well. Thus, there are a small number of data points used for this report that differ from what is published in the NCAA report. NCAA Closed-Group Athletic Data To isolate the effect of school-level decisions to add, drop, expand, or contract sport teams on athletic trends from (a) the changing NCAA membership, (b) the effect of schools being members of both the NCAA and another athletic association and not reporting comprehensive athletic information to the NCAA, and (c) inconsistent annual reporting by certain schools, we constructed, in concert with the NCAA, a fixed, or "closed," group of schools that met all three (3) of the following criteria: o They were members of the NCAA in each year from 1991-1992 to 2004-2005. o They were not also members of the second-largest athletic association, the NAIA, in any year from 1991-1992 to 2004-2005. o They reported team and participant information in each year from 1991-1992 to 2004-2005. This yielded a group of 750 schools, or just over 88 percent of the overall NCAA membership in 1991-1992 and just under 72 percent of the overall membership in 2004-2005. Of this group, 14 schools reported to Education via IPEDS that they were also members of an athletic organization other than the NAIA in at least one year of our study period. To the extent that these schools progressively reported more of their female sport information to the NCAA over time, increases in female trends relative to male trends may be slightly overstated. To the extent that these schools progressively reported more of their male sport information over time, increases in female trends relative to male trends may be slightly understated. The NCAA has retained school-level team and participant data for its entire membership from the 1991-1992 school year to the present. Because the NCAA classifies its school-level information as private, the NCAA analyzed team and participant data for this closed group in-house and then provided aggregate figures for this closed group and the programming code used to generate these figures. NCAA officials noted that data for school years 1993-1994, 1998-1999, and 2000-2001 may be slightly less consistent than data for the other school years of the study period. We reviewed the NCAA's programming code and had the NCAA make adjustments and corrections where necessary. We examined the internal consistency of the data for the closed group that resulted from this code by comparing aggregate figures to the sum of disaggregated figures and by examining year-to-year fluctuations in the athletic data. We also compared figures for the closed-group to the equivalent figures for the open group. Where internal inconsistency, inconsistency between the open and closed group, or large and unexplained fluctuations were found, we eliminated those data from our analysis, as discussed below. Through our assessment and the elimination of inconsistent data, we determined that data used for the closed group were sufficient for the purposes of our report. Sport-by-Sport Analyses Our sport-by-sport and aggregate figures reflect the 14 men's and 13 women's sports that had team and participant information reported throughout the study period, that are comparable across the open and closed groups, and for which male and female data exist separately. This report does not contain all the results of our trend analysis. A more detailed analysis by sport can be viewed at [19]GAO-07-744SP . With regard to reporting consistency, the NCAA has retained historical figures for each of its sports for each year in which either the sport was identified as emerging or the NCAA held a championship for that sport as well as various other years. To the extent that several sports have emerged or added a championship since the 1991-1992 school year, data tend to be more comprehensive across the 54 NCAA sports in recent years relative to the beginning of our study period. However, to become an emerging sport, there must already be 20 or more NCAA-sponsored and/or competitive club teams that exist in that sport, and there must be other signs of sustained and increasing interest in the sport. Thus, nonentries in a given year of NCAA data do not necessarily reflect a lack of sponsorship or participation in that year. Furthermore, several sports have data for the beginning and end of our study period, but not the intervening years. To account for the inconsistency of reporting across sports and across time, the NCAA included in its customized data only the subset of sports for which data were reported in each year of the study period. To enable a direct comparison between the open and closed groups, we analyzed only those sports for which data existed in each year and in both the open and closed groups. The sports included in the closed-group data narrowed the list of included sports substantially, but we also compared figures across the two groups for external consistency as well. In particular, we eliminated four sports where aggregate figures for the closed group were larger than aggregate figures for the open group, which is impossible by construction. With regard to the reporting of male and female participant counts, the NCAA has reported male and female athletic data for coed/mixed-gender sports differently over time. For some years, overall participant counts for mixed-gender sports were divided in half when allocated to male and female participant counts, and for other years actual counts were recorded. Because of this inconsistency in reporting, participant counts for sports such as fencing, rifle, and skiing for certain years may not reflect actual male and female participants, and thus these sports were not included in this report. In summary, the sports we analyzed (a) have data reported in each year of the study period, (b) were common to or reported in both groups of data analyzed (open group and closed group), and (c) excluded certain coed-mixed gender sports because of inconsistent reporting across the study period. Ultimately, this yielded the 14 men's and 13 women's sports analyzed in this report, whose participants reflect 98 percent of the NCAA's overall male participation and 99 percent of the overall female participation in 1991-1992, and 99 percent and 93 percent of male and female participation, respectively, in 2004-2005. See Table 2 for the sports included in the NCAA report and analyzed for this report. Table 2: Sports Included in the NCAA Report and Analyzed for This Report Men's sports Men's sports Women's sports Women's sports included in both the included only included in both the included only in NCAA and GAO reports in the NCAA NCAA and GAO reports the NCAA report (14) report (13) (13) (14) Baseball Archery Basketball Archery Basketball Badminton Cross-Country Badminton Cross-Country Bowling Field Hockey Bowling Football Equestrian Golf Equestrian Golf Fencing Gymnastics Fencing Ice Hockey Gymnastics Lacrosse Ice Hockey Lacrosse Rifle Soccer Rifle Soccer Rowing Softball Rowing Swimming/Diving Rugby Swimming/Diving Rugby Tennis Sailing Tennis Skiing Track, Indoor Skiing Track, Indoor Squash Track, Outdoor Squash Track, Outdoor Synchronized Swimming Volleyball Water Polo Volleyball Team Handball Wrestling Water Polo Source: GAO analysis. Department of Education Enrollment Data For both aggregate and school-level enrollment, we obtained full-time, undergraduate enrollment data from IPEDS, which is the core postsecondary education data collection program for the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), which, in turn, is the primary federal entity for collecting and analyzing data related to education. Specifically, IPEDS is a single, comprehensive system of surveys designed to collect institution-level data from all primary providers of postsecondary education in such areas as student enrollment and program completion, faculty and staff characteristics, and school finances. We obtained aggregate enrollment data for both the open and closed groups based on the schools listed in the annual NCAA membership directories and the list of 750 schools included in the closed group. These data are the basis for our aggregate comparisons between participation and enrollment, presented in slides 19 and 20 of appendix I. Officials from Education noted that the agency did not complete data reliability testing for the purpose of extrapolating reported institutional data from the 1999-2000 school year to generate aggregate figures because reporting for this earlier period was optional to the schools and reporting rates were particularly low for this year. Thus, we did not include aggregate figures for 1999-2000 for this analysis. For the school-level comparisons between participation and enrollment, we provided the NCAA with school-by-school enrollment for each year in our study period for schools that reported enrollment information through IPEDS in each year and that had male and female enrollment each of at least 100 in each year of the study period, characterized as "coed schools." In addition, several college and university campuses reported either athletic data to the NCAA or enrollment data to Education jointly with other campuses. To ensure the compatibility of athletic and enrollment data, we merged the data for these campuses together and treated the campuses collectively as one unit. This resulted in enrollment data being provided for 715 schools or school-campus combinations in the closed group, and the resultant NCAA analysis is what is presented in slide 21 of appendix I. Although Education has not released enrollment figures for 1999-2000 for aggregate reporting purposes, officials from Education noted that data that have been reported are reliable for school-level reporting purposes, so 1999-2000 is included in this analysis. Because IPEDS data are statistical agency data that are collected and audited within the NCES, we focused our reliability testing on the consistency between internal NCES data documentation and downloaded data, and we examined the consistency of summary statistics and the frequency of missing values across years. Our testing found no differences between our files and the IPEDS data dictionaries, no unusual increases in the frequency of missing variables across years (other than for 1999-2000), and no changes in the mean or standard deviation of enrollment above 5 percent and no changes in the maximum or minimum enrollment per school above 10 percent from one year to the next. In addition, NCES has completed individual data reliability testing for its 1991-1992 through 2005-2006 data and released a 2005 report detailing the reliability of its enrollment data, among other data. (See [20]http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2005175 to access this report.) Therefore, we determined that the IPEDS enrollment data are sufficiently reliable for the purposes of this report. Appendix III: Schools Included in the Open Group The following 1,052 schools were included in the overall NCAA membership for at least one year from 1991-1992 to 2004-2005. This list is based on the NCAA's annual membership lists for this period. Table 3: Open-Group Schools (state abbreviation) Abilene Christian University (Tex.) Armstrong Atlantic State University (Ga.) Adams State College (Colo.) Asbury College (Ky.) Adelphi University (N.Y.) Ashland University (Ohio) Adrian College (Mich.) Assumption College (Mass.) Agnes Scott College (Ga.) Auburn University Main Campus Alabama A & M University (Ala.) (Ala.) Alabama State University (Ala.) Augsburg College (Minn.) Albany State University (Ga.) Augusta State University (Ga.) Albertus Magnus College (Conn.) Augustana College (Ill.) Albion College (Mich.) Augustana College (S.D.) Albright College (Pa.) Aurora University (Ill.) Alcorn State University (Miss.) Austin College (Tex.) Alderson Broaddus College (W.Va.) Austin Peay State University (Tenn.) Alfred University (N.Y.) Averett University (Va.) Allegheny College (Pa.) Babson College (Mass.) Alma College (Mich.) Baldwin-Wallace College (Ohio) Alvernia College (Pa.) Ball State University (Ind.) Alverno College (Wis.) Baptist Bible College and Seminary American International College (Mass.) (Pa.) American University (D.C.) Bard College (N.Y.) American University of Puerto Rico Barnard College (N.Y.) (P.R.) Barry University (Fla.) Amherst College (Mass.) Barton College (N.C.) Anderson College (S.C.) Bates College (Maine) Anderson University (Ind.) Bay Path College (Mass.) Angelo State University (Tex.) Baylor University (Tex.) Anna Maria College (Mass.) Becker College (Mass.) Appalachian State University (N.C.) Bellarmine University (Ky.) Arcadia University (Pa.) Belmont Abbey College (N.C.) Arizona State University at the Tempe Campus (Ariz.) Belmont University (Tenn.) Arkansas State University-Main Campus Beloit College (Wis.) (Ark.) Bemidji State University (Minn.) Arkansas Tech University (Ark.) Benedict College (S.C.) Benedictine University (Ill.) Bennett College (N.C.) California State University-Bakersfield (Calif.) Bentley College (Mass.) California State University-Chico Berea College (Ky.) (Calif.) Bethany College (W.Va.) California State University-Dominguez Hills (Calif.) Bethel University (Minn.) California State University-East Bay Bethune Cookman College (Fla.) (Calif.) Birmingham Southern College (Ala.) California State University-Fresno (Calif.) Blackburn College (Ill.) California State University-Fullerton Bloomfield College (N.J.) (Calif.) Bloomsburg University of California State University-Long Pennsylvania (Pa.) Beach (Calif.) Bluefield State College (W.Va.) California State University-Los Angeles (Calif.) Bluffton University (Ohio) California State Boise State University (Idaho) University-Northridge (Calif.) Boston College (Mass.) California State University-Sacramento (Calif.) Boston University (Mass.) California State University-San Bowdoin College (Maine) Bernardino (Calif.) Bowie State University (Md.) California State University-Stanislaus (Calif.) Bowling Green State University-Main Campus (Ohio) California University of Pennsylvania (Pa.) Bradley University (Ill.) Calvin College (Mich.) Brandeis University (Mass.) Cameron University (Okla.) Bridgewater College (Va.) Campbell University Inc (N.C.) Bridgewater State College (Mass.) Canisius College (N.Y.) Brigham Young University (Utah) Capital University (Ohio) Brigham Young University-Hawaii Campus (Hawaii) Carleton College (Minn.) Brown University (R.I.) Carnegie Mellon University (Pa.) Bryant University (R.I.) Carroll College (Wis.) Bryn Mawr College (Pa.) Carson-Newman College (Tenn.) Bucknell University (Pa.) Carthage College (Wis.) Buena Vista University (Iowa) Case Western Reserve University (Ohio) Butler University (Ind.) Castleton State College (Vt.) Cabrini College (Pa.) Catawba College (N.C.) Caldwell College (N.J.) Catholic University of America (D.C.) California Institute of Technology (Calif.) Cazenovia College (N.Y.) California Lutheran University Cedar Crest College (Pa.) (Calif.) Centenary College (N.J.) California Polytechnic State University-San Luis Obispo (Calif.) Centenary College of Louisiana (La.) California State Polytechnic University-Pomona (Calif.) Central College (Iowa) College of Saint Benedict (Minn.) Central Connecticut State University College of Saint Elizabeth (N.J.) (Conn.) College of St Catherine (Minn.) Central Michigan University (Mich.) College of the Holy Cross (Mass.) Central Missouri State University (Mo.) College of William and Mary (Va.) Central Washington University (Wash.) College of Wooster (Ohio) Centre College (Ky.) Colorado Christian University (Colo.) Chadron State College (Neb.) Colorado College (Colo.) Chaminade University of Honolulu (Hawaii) Colorado School of Mines (Colo.) Chapman University (Calif.) Colorado State University (Colo.) Charleston Southern University (S.C.) Colorado State University-Pueblo (Colo.) Chatham College (Pa.) Columbia Union College (Md.) Chestnut Hill College (Pa.) Columbia University in the City of Cheyney University of Pennsylvania New York (N.Y.) (Pa.) Columbus State University (Ga.) Chicago State University (Ill.) Concord University (W.Va.) Chowan College (N.C.) Concordia College (N.Y.) Christian Brothers University (Tenn.) Concordia College at Moorhead Christopher Newport University (Va.) (Minn.) Citadel Military College of South Concordia University (Ill.) Carolina (S.C.) Concordia University at Austin Claremont McKenna College (Calif.) (Tex.) Clarion University of Pennsylvania Concordia University-St Paul (Minn.) (Pa.) Concordia University-Wisconsin Clark Atlanta University (Ga.) (Wis.) Clark University (Mass.) Connecticut College (Conn.) Clarke College (Iowa) Converse College (S.C.) Clarkson University (N.Y.) Coppin State University (Md.) Clayton College and State University Cornell College (Iowa) (Ga.) Cornell University-Endowed Colleges Clemson University (S.C.) (N.Y.) Cleveland State University (Ohio) Creighton University (Neb.) Coastal Carolina University (S.C.) CUNY Bernard M Baruch College (N.Y.) Coe College (Iowa) CUNY Brooklyn College (N.Y.) Coker College (S.C.) CUNY City College (N.Y.) Colby College (Maine) CUNY College of Staten Island (N.Y.) Colby-Sawyer College (N.H.) CUNY Hunter College (N.Y.) Colgate University (N.Y.) CUNY John Jay College Criminal Justice (N.Y.) College Misericordia (Pa.) CUNY Lehman College (N.Y.) College of Charleston (S.C.) CUNY Medgar Evers College (N.Y.) College of Mount Saint Joseph (Ohio) CUNY New York City College of College of Mount Saint Vincent (N.Y.) Technology (N.Y.) College of Notre Dame of Maryland CUNY Queens College (N.Y.) (Md.) College of Our Lady of the Elms (Mass.) CUNY York College (N.Y.) Eastern New Mexico University-Main Campus (N.M.) Curry College (Mass.) Eastern Oregon University (Ore.) Dallas Baptist University (Tex.) Eastern University (Pa.) Daniel Webster College (N.H.) Eastern Washington University Dartmouth College (N.H.) (Wash.) Davidson College (N.C.) Eckerd College (Fla.) Davis and Elkins College (W.Va.) Edgewood College (Wis.) Defiance College (Ohio) Edinboro University of Pennsylvania (Pa.) Delaware State University (Del.) Elizabeth City State University Delaware Valley College (Pa.) (N.C.) Delta State University (Miss.) Elizabethtown College (Pa.) Denison University (Ohio) Elmhurst College (Ill.) Depaul University (Ill.) Elmira College (N.Y.) Depauw University (Ind.) Elon University (N.C.) Desales University (Pa.) Emerson College (Mass.) Dickinson College (Pa.) Emmanuel College (Mass.) Dominican College of Blauvelt (N.Y.) Emory and Henry College (Va.) Dominican University (Ill.) Emory University (Ga.) Dowling College (N.Y.) Emporia State University (Kan.) Drake University (Iowa) Endicott College (Mass.) Drew University (N.J.) Erskine College and Seminary (S.C.) Drexel University (Pa.) Eureka College (Ill.) Drury University (Mo.) Fairfield University (Conn.) Duke University (N.C.) Fairleigh Dickinson University-College at Florham (N.J.) Duquesne University (Pa.) Fairleigh Dickinson D'Youville College (N.Y.) University-Metropolitan Campus (N.J.) Earlham College (Ind.) Fairmont State University (W.Va.) East Carolina University (N.C.) Farmingdale State University of New East Central University (Okla.) York (N.Y.) East Stroudsburg University of Fayetteville State University (N.C.) Pennsylvania (Pa.) Felician College (N.J.) East Tennessee State University (Tenn.) Ferris State University (Mich.) East Texas Baptist University (Tex.) Ferrum College (Va.) Eastern Connecticut State University Fisk University (Tenn.) (Conn.) Fitchburg State College (Mass.) Eastern Illinois University (Ill.) Florida Agricultural and Mechanical Eastern Kentucky University (Ky.) University (Fla.) Eastern Mennonite University (Va.) Florida Atlantic University-Boca Raton (Fla.) Eastern Michigan University (Mich.) Florida Gulf Coast University (Fla.) Eastern Nazarene College (Mass.) Florida Institute of Greensboro College (N.C.) Technology-Melbourne (Fla.) Greenville College (Ill.) Florida International University (Fla.) Grinnell College (Iowa) Florida Southern College (Fla.) Grove City College (Pa.) Florida State University (Fla.) Guilford College (N.C.) Fontbonne University (Mo.) Gustavus Adolphus College (Minn.) Fordham University (N.Y.) Gwynedd Mercy College (Pa.) Fort Hays State University (Kan.) Hamilton College (N.Y.) Fort Lewis College (Colo.) Hamline University (Minn.) Fort Valley State University (Ga.) Hampden-Sydney College (Va.) Framingham State College (Mass.) Hampton University (Va.) Francis Marion University (S.C.) Hanover College (Ind.) Franklin and Marshall College (Pa.) Harding University (Ark.) Franklin College (Ind.) Hardin-Simmons University (Tex.) Franklin Pierce College (N.H.) Hartwick College (N.Y.) Frostburg State University (Md.) Harvard University (Mass.) Furman University (S.C.) Harvey Mudd College (Calif.) Gallaudet University (D.C.) Haverford College (Pa.) Gannon University (Pa.) Hawaii Pacific University (Hawaii) Gardner-Webb University (N.C.) Heidelberg College (Ohio) George Fox University (Ore.) Henderson State University (Ark.) George Mason University (Va.) Hendrix College (Ark.) George Washington University (D.C.) High Point University (N.C.) Georgetown University (D.C.) Hilbert College (N.Y.) Georgia College and State University Hillsdale College (Mich.) (Ga.) Hiram College (Ohio) Georgia Institute of Technology-Main Campus (Ga.) Hobart William Smith Colleges (N.Y.) Georgia Southern University (Ga.) Hofstra University (N.Y.) Georgia State University (Ga.) Hollins University (Va.) Georgian Court University (N.J.) Holy Family University (Pa.) Gettysburg College (Pa.) Hood College (Md.) Glenville State College (W.Va.) Hope College (Mich.) Goldey-Beacom College (Del.) Howard Payne University (Tex.) Gonzaga University (Wash.) Howard University (D.C.) Gordon College (Mass.) Humboldt State University (Calif.) Goucher College (Md.) Huntingdon College (Ala.) Grambling State University (La.) Husson College (Maine) Grand Canyon University (Ariz.) Idaho State University (Idaho) Grand Valley State University (Mich.) Illinois College (Ill.) Green Mountain College (Vt.) Illinois State University (Ill.) Lafayette College (Pa.) Illinois Wesleyan University (Ill.) Lagrange College (Ga.) Immaculata University (Pa.) Lake Erie College (Ohio) Indiana State University (Ind.) Lake Forest College (Ill.) Indiana University of Lake Superior State University Pennsylvania-Main Campus (Pa.) (Mich.) Indiana University-Bloomington (Ind.) Lakeland College (Wis.) Indiana University-Purdue Lamar University (Tex.) University-Fort Wayne (Ind.) Lander University (S.C.) Indiana University-Purdue University-Indianapolis (Ind.) Lane College (Tenn.) Iona College (N.Y.) Lasell College (Mass.) Iowa State University (Iowa) Lawrence University (Wis.) Ithaca College (N.Y.) Le Moyne College (N.Y.) Jackson State University (Miss.) Le Moyne-Owen College (Tenn.) Jacksonville State University (Ala.) Lebanon Valley College (Pa.) Jacksonville University (Fla.) Lees-Mcrae College (N.C.) James Madison University (Va.) Lehigh University (Pa.) Jarvis Christian College (Tex.) Lenoir-Rhyne College (N.C.) John Carroll University (Ohio) Lesley University (Mass.) Johns Hopkins University (Md.) Letourneau University (Tex.) Johnson & Wales University (R.I.) Lewis & Clark College (Ore.) Johnson C Smith University (N.C.) Lewis University (Ill.) Johnson State College (Vt.) Liberty University (Va.) Juniata College (Pa.) Limestone College (S.C.) Kalamazoo College (Mich.) Lincoln Memorial University (Tenn.) Kansas State University (Kan.) Lincoln University (Mo.) Kean University (N.J.) Lincoln University (Pa.) Keene State College (N.H.) Linfield College (Ore.) Kennesaw State University (Ga.) Lipscomb University (Tenn.) Kent State University-Main Campus Livingstone College (N.C.) (Ohio) Lock Haven University of Kentucky State University (Ky.) Pennsylvania (Pa.) Kentucky Wesleyan College (Ky.) Long Island University-Brooklyn Campus (N.Y.) Kenyon College (Ohio) Long Island University-C W Post Keuka College (N.Y.) Campus (N.Y.) Kings College (Pa.) Longwood University (Va.) Knox College (Ill.) Loras College (Iowa) Kutztown University of Pennsylvania Louisiana College (La.) (Pa.) Louisiana State Univ & Ag & Mech & La Roche College (Pa.) Hebert Laws Ctr (La.) La Salle University (Pa.) Louisiana Tech University (La.) Meredith College (N.C.) Loyola College in Maryland (Md.) Merrimack College (Mass.) Loyola Marymount University (Calif.) Mesa State College (Colo.) Loyola University Chicago (Ill.) Messiah College (Pa.) Luther College (Iowa) Methodist College (N.C.) Lycoming College (Pa.) Metropolitan State College of Denver (Colo.) Lynchburg College (Va.) Miami University-Oxford (Ohio) Lynn University (Fla.) Michigan State University (Mich.) Macalester College (Minn.) Michigan Technological University MacMurray College (Ill.) (Mich.) Maine Maritime Academy (Maine) Middle Tennessee State University (Tenn.) Manchester College (Ind.) Middlebury College (Vt.) Manhattan College (N.Y.) Midwestern State University (Tex.) Manhattanville College (N.Y.) Miles College (Ala.) Mansfield University of Pennsylvania (Pa.) Millersville University of Pennsylvania (Pa.) Maranatha Baptist Bible College Inc (Wis.) Millikin University (Ill.) Marian College of Fond Du Lac (Wis.) Mills College (Calif.) Marietta College (Ohio) Millsaps College (Miss.) Marist College (N.Y.) Milwaukee School of Engineering (Wis.) Marquette University (Wis.) Minnesota State University-Mankato Mars Hill College (N.C.) (Minn.) Marshall University (W.Va.) Minnesota State University-Moorhead (Minn.) Martin Luther College (Minn.) Mississippi College (Miss.) Mary Baldwin College (Va.) Mississippi State University (Miss.) Marymount University (Va.) Mississippi University For Women Maryville College (Tenn.) (Miss.) Maryville University of Saint Louis Mississippi Valley State University (Mo.) (Miss.) Marywood University (Pa.) Missouri Southern State University (Mo.) Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts (Mass.) Missouri Western State College (Mo.) Massachusetts Institute of Technology Molloy College (N.Y.) (Mass.) Monmouth College (Ill.) Massachusetts Maritime Academy (Mass.) Monmouth University (N.J.) McDaniel College (Md.) Montana State University-Billings (Mont.) McMurry University (Tex.) Montana State University-Bozeman McNeese State University (La.) (Mont.) Medaille College (N.Y.) Montclair State University (N.J.) Menlo College (Calif.) Moravian College and Theological Seminary (Pa.) Mercer University (Ga.) Mercy College-Main Campus (N.Y.) Mercyhurst College (Pa.) Morehead State University (Ky.) North Park University (Ill.) Morehouse College (Ga.) Northeastern Illinois University (Ill.) Morgan State University (Md.) Northeastern State University Morningside College (Iowa) (Okla.) Morris Brown College (Ga.) Northeastern University (Mass.) Mount Holyoke College (Mass.) Northern Arizona University (Ariz.) Mount Ida College (Mass.) Northern Illinois University (Ill.) Mount Olive College (N.C.) Northern Kentucky University (Ky.) Mount Saint Mary College (N.Y.) Northern Michigan University (Mich.) Mount St Mary's University (Md.) Northern State University (S.D.) Mount Union College (Ohio) Northland College (Wis.) Muhlenberg College (Pa.) Northwest Missouri State University (Mo.) Murray State University (Ky.) Northwest Nazarene University Muskingum College (Ohio) (Idaho) Nazareth College of Rochester (N.Y.) Northwestern College (Wis.) Nebraska Wesleyan University (Neb.) Northwestern State University of Louisiana (La.) Neumann College (Pa.) Northwestern University (Ill.) New England College (N.H.) Northwood University (Mich.) New Jersey City University (N.J.) Norwich University (Vt.) New Jersey Institute of Technology (N.J.) Notre Dame De Namur University (Calif.) New Mexico Highlands University (N.M.) Nova Southeastern University (Fla.) New Mexico State University-Main Nyack College (N.Y.) Campus (N.M.) Oakland City University (Ind.) New York Institute of Technology-Old Westbury (N.Y.) Oakland University (Mich.) New York University (N.Y.) Oberlin College (Ohio) Newberry College (S.C.) Occidental College (Calif.) Newbury College-Brookline (Mass.) Oglethorpe University (Ga.) Niagara University (N.Y.) Ohio Northern University (Ohio) Nicholls State University (La.) Ohio State University-Main Campus (Ohio) Nichols College (Mass.) Ohio University-Main Campus (Ohio) Norfolk State University (Va.) Ohio Valley College (W.Va.) North Carolina A & T State University (N.C.) Ohio Wesleyan University (Ohio) North Carolina Central University Oklahoma Panhandle State University (N.C.) (Okla.) North Carolina State University at Oklahoma State University-Main Raleigh (N.C.) Campus (Okla.) North Carolina Wesleyan College Old Dominion University (Va.) (N.C.) Olivet College (Mich.) North Central College (Ill.) Oral Roberts University (Okla.) North Dakota State University-Main Campus (N.D.) Oregon State University (Ore.) North Greenville College (S.C.) Otterbein College (Ohio) Regis University (Colo.) Ouachita Baptist University (Ark.) Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (N.Y.) Pace University-New York (N.Y.) Rhode Island College (R.I.) Pacific Lutheran University (Wash.) Rhodes College (Tenn.) Pacific University (Ore.) Rice University (Tex.) Paine College (Ga.) Rider University (N.J.) Peace College (N.C.) Ripon College (Wis.) Pennsylvania State University-Main Campus (Pa.) Rivier College (N.H.) Pennsylvania State University-Penn Roanoke College (Va.) State Altoona (Pa.) Robert Morris University (Pa.) Pennsylvania State Univ-Penn St Erie-Behrend Coll (Pa.) Rochester Institute of Technology (N.Y.) Pepperdine University (Calif.) Rockford College (Ill.) Pfeiffer University (N.C.) Rockhurst University (Mo.) Philadelphia Biblical University-Langhorne (Pa.) Roger Williams University (R.I.) Philadelphia University (Pa.) Rollins College (Fla.) Piedmont College (Ga.) Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology (Ind.) Pine Manor College (Mass.) Rosemont College (Pa.) Pittsburg State University (Kan.) Rowan University (N.J.) Pitzer College (Calif.) Rust College (Miss.) Plymouth State University (N.H.) Rutgers University-Camden (N.J.) Polytechnic University (N.Y.) Rutgers University-New Brunswick Pomona College (Calif.) (N.J.) Portland State University (Ore.) Rutgers University-Newark (N.J.) Post University (Conn.) Sacred Heart University (Conn.) Prairie View A & M University (Tex.) Saginaw Valley State University (Mich.) Presbyterian College (S.C.) Saint Anselm College (N.H.) Princeton University (N.J.) Saint Augustines College (N.C.) Principia College (Ill.) Saint Bonaventure University (N.Y.) Providence College (R.I.) Saint Cloud State University (Minn.) Purdue University-Main Campus (Ind.) Saint Edward's University (Tex.) Queens University of Charlotte (N.C.) Saint Francis University (Pa.) Quincy University (Ill.) Saint John Fisher College (N.Y.) Quinnipiac University (Conn.) Saint Johns University (Minn.) Radford University (Va.) Saint Joseph College (Conn.) Ramapo College of New Jersey (N.J.) Saint Josephs College (Ind.) Randolph-Macon College (Va.) Saint Josephs College (Maine) Randolph-Macon Woman's College (Va.) Saint Josephs College-Suffolk Campus Regis College (Mass.) (N.Y.) Saint Josephs University (Pa.) Saint Leo University (Fla.) Saint Louis University-Main Campus Slippery Rock University of (Mo.) Pennsylvania (Pa.) Saint Martins College (Wash.) Smith College (Mass.) Saint Mary's College (Ind.) Sonoma State University (Calif.) Saint Marys College of California South Carolina State University (Calif.) (S.C.) Saint Mary's University of Minnesota South Dakota State University (S.D.) (Minn.) Southampton College of Long Island Saint Michaels College (Vt.) University (N.Y.) Saint Norbert College (Wis.) Southeast Missouri State University (Mo.) Saint Olaf College (Minn.) Southeastern Louisiana University Saint Pauls College (Va.) (La.) Saint Peters College (N.J.) Southeastern Oklahoma State University (Okla.) Saint Thomas Aquinas College (N.Y.) Southern Arkansas University Main Salem International University Campus (Ark.) (W.Va.) Southern Connecticut State Salem State College (Mass.) University (Conn.) Salisbury University (Md.) Southern Illinois University Carbondale (Ill.) Salve Regina University (R.I.) Southern Illinois University Sam Houston State University (Tex.) Edwardsville (Ill.) Samford University (Ala.) Southern Methodist University (Tex.) San Diego State University (Calif.) Southern New Hampshire University (N.H.) San Francisco State University (Calif.) Southern University and A & M College (La.) San Jose State University (Calif.) Southern Utah University (Utah) Santa Clara University (Calif.) Southern Vermont College (Vt.) Savannah College of Art and Design (Ga.) Southwest Baptist University (Mo.) Savannah State University (Ga.) Southwest Minnesota State University (Minn.) Schreiner University (Tex.) Southwest Missouri State University Scripps College (Calif.) (Mo.) Seattle Pacific University (Wash.) Southwestern Oklahoma State University (Okla.) Seattle University (Wash.) Southwestern University (Tex.) Seton Hall University (N.J.) Spelman College (Ga.) Sewanee: The University of the South (Tenn.) Springfield College (Mass.) Shaw University (N.C.) St Andrews Presbyterian College (N.C.) Shenandoah University (Va.) St Francis College (N.Y.) Shepherd University (W.Va.) St John's University-New York (N.Y.) Shippensburg University of Pennsylvania (Pa.) St Lawrence University (N.Y.) Siena College (N.Y.) Simmons College (Mass.) Simpson College (Iowa) Skidmore College (N.Y.) St Mary's College of Maryland (Md.) Texas A & M University-Commerce (Tex.) St Marys University (Tex.) Texas A & M University-Corpus Stanford University (Calif.) Christi (Tex.) State University of West Georgia Texas A & M University-Kingsville (Ga.) (Tex.) Stephen F Austin State University Texas Christian University (Tex.) (Tex.) Texas Lutheran University (Tex.) Stephens College (Mo.) Texas Southern University (Tex.) Stetson University (Fla.) Texas State University-San Marcos Stevens Institute of Technology (Tex.) (N.J.) Texas Tech University (Tex.) Stillman College (Ala.) Texas Woman's University (Tex.) Stonehill College (Mass.) The College of New Jersey (N.J.) Suffolk University (Mass.) The College of New Rochelle (N.Y.) Sul Ross State University (Tex.) The College of Saint Rose (N.Y.) SUNY at Albany (N.Y.) The College of Saint Scholastica SUNY at Binghamton (N.Y.) (Minn.) SUNY at Buffalo (N.Y.) The Richard Stockton College of New Jersey (N.J.) SUNY at Stony Brook (N.Y.) The Sage Colleges-Troy Campus (N.Y.) SUNY College at Brockport (N.Y.) The University of Alabama (Ala.) SUNY College at Buffalo (N.Y.) The University of Findlay (Ohio) SUNY College at Cortland (N.Y.) The University of Montana-Missoula SUNY College at Fredonia (N.Y.) (Mont.) SUNY College at Geneseo (N.Y.) The University of Tampa (Fla.) SUNY College at New Paltz (N.Y.) The University of Tennessee (Tenn.) SUNY College at Old Westbury (N.Y.) The University of Tennessee-Chattanooga (Tenn.) SUNY College at Oneonta (N.Y.) The University of Tennessee-Martin SUNY College at Oswego (N.Y.) (Tenn.) SUNY College at Plattsburgh (N.Y.) The University of Texas at Arlington (Tex.) SUNY Institute of Technology at Utica-Rome (N.Y.) The University of Texas at Austin (Tex.) SUNY Maritime College (N.Y.) The University of Texas at Dallas SUNY-Potsdam (N.Y.) (Tex.) Susquehanna University (Pa.) The University of Texas at El Paso (Tex.) Swarthmore College (Pa.) The University of Texas at San Sweet Briar College (Va.) Antonio (Tex.) Syracuse University (N.Y.) The University of Texas-Pan American (Tex.) Tarleton State University (Tex.) The University of West Florida Temple University (Pa.) (Fla.) Tennessee State University (Tenn.) Thiel College (Pa.) Tennessee Technological University Thomas College (Maine) (Tenn.) Thomas More College (Ky.) Texas A & M University (Tex.) Tiffin University (Ohio) University of Central Oklahoma (Okla.) Towson University (Md.) University of Charleston (W.Va.) Transylvania University (Ky.) University of Chicago (Ill.) Trinity College (Conn.) University of Cincinnati-Main Campus Trinity University (D.C.) (Ohio) Trinity University (Tex.) University of Colorado at Boulder (Colo.) Troy State University-Main Campus (Ala.) University of Colorado at Colorado Springs (Colo.) Truman State University (Mo.) University of Connecticut (Conn.) Tufts University (Mass.) University of Dallas (Tex.) Tulane University of Louisiana (La.) University of Dayton (Ohio) Tusculum College (Tenn.) University of Delaware (Del.) Tuskegee University (Ala.) University of Denver (Colo.) Union College (N.Y.) University of Detroit Mercy (Mich.) United States Air Force Academy (Colo.) University of Dubuque (Iowa) United States Coast Guard Academy University of Evansville (Ind.) (Conn.) University of Florida (Fla.) United States Merchant Marine Academy (N.Y.) University of Georgia (Ga.) United States Military Academy (N.Y.) University of Hartford (Conn.) United States Naval Academy (Md.) University of Hawaii at Hilo (Hawaii) University of Akron Main Campus (Ohio) University of Hawaii at Manoa (Hawaii) University of Alabama at Birmingham (Ala.) University of Houston-University Park (Tex.) University of Alabama in Huntsville (Ala.) University of Idaho (Idaho) University of Alaska Anchorage University of Illinois at Chicago (Alaska) (Ill.) University of Alaska Fairbanks University of Illinois at (Alaska) Urbana-Champaign (Ill.) University of Arizona (Ariz.) University of Indianapolis (Ind.) University of Arkansas at Little Rock University of Iowa (Iowa) (Ark.) University of Kansas Main Campus University of Arkansas at Monticello (Kan.) (Ark.) University of Kentucky (Ky.) University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff (Ark.) University of La Verne (Calif.) University of Arkansas Main Campus University of Louisiana at Lafayette (Ark.) (La.) University of Bridgeport (Conn.) University of Louisiana at Monroe (La.) University of California-Berkeley (Calif.) University of Louisville (Ky.) University of California-Davis University of Maine (Maine) (Calif.) University of Maine at Farmington University of California-Irvine (Maine) (Calif.) University of Mary Hardin-Baylor University of California-Los Angeles (Tex.) (Calif.) University of Mary Washington (Va.) University of California-Riverside (Calif.) University of California-San Diego (Calif.) University of California-Santa Barbara (Calif.) University of California-Santa Cruz (Calif.) University of Central Arkansas (Ark.) University of Central Florida (Fla.) University of Maryland-Baltimore University of North Carolina at County (Md.) Greensboro (N.C.) University of Maryland-College Park University of North Carolina at (Md.) Pembroke (N.C.) University of Maryland-Eastern Shore University of North (Md.) Carolina-Wilmington (N.C.) University of Massachusetts-Amherst University of North Dakota-Main (Mass.) Campus (N.D.) University of Massachusetts-Boston University of North Florida (Fla.) (Mass.) University of North Texas (Tex.) University of Massachusetts-Dartmouth (Mass.) University of Northern Colorado (Colo.) University of Massachusetts-Lowell (Mass.) University of Northern Iowa (Iowa) University of Memphis (Tenn.) University of Notre Dame (Ind.) University of Miami (Fla.) University of Oklahoma Norman Campus (Okla.) University of Michigan-Ann Arbor (Mich.) University of Oregon (Ore.) University of Minnesota-Crookston University of Pennsylvania (Pa.) (Minn.) University of Pittsburgh-Bradford University of Minnesota-Duluth (Pa.) (Minn.) University of Pittsburgh-Greensburg University of Minnesota-Morris (Pa.) (Minn.) University of Pittsburgh-Johnstown University of Minnesota-Twin Cities (Pa.) (Minn.) University of Pittsburgh-Main Campus University of Mississippi Main Campus (Pa.) (Miss.) University of Portland (Ore.) University of Missouri-Columbia (Mo.) University of Puerto Rico-Bayamon University of Missouri-Kansas City (P.R.) (Mo.) University of Puerto Rico-Cayey University of Missouri-Rolla (Mo.) University College (P.R.) University of Missouri-St Louis (Mo.) University of Puerto Rico-Humacao (P.R.) University of Montevallo (Ala.) University of Puerto Rico-Mayaguez University of Nebraska at Kearney (P.R.) (Neb.) University of Puerto Rico-Rio University of Nebraska at Lincoln Piedras Campus (P.R.) (Neb.) University of Puget Sound (Wash.) University of Nebraska at Omaha (Neb.) University of Redlands (Calif.) University of Nevada-Las Vegas (Nev.) University of Rhode Island (R.I.) University of Nevada-Reno (Nev.) University of Richmond (Va.) University of New England (Maine) University of Rochester (N.Y.) University of New Hampshire-Main University of San Diego (Calif.) Campus (N.H.) University of San Francisco (Calif.) University of New Haven (Conn.) University of Scranton (Pa.) University of New Mexico-Main Campus (N.M.) University of South Alabama (Ala.) University of New Orleans (La.) University of North Alabama (Ala.) University of North Carolina at Asheville (N.C.) University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (N.C.) University of North Carolina at Charlotte (N.C.) University of South Carolina Upstate Upper Iowa University (Iowa) (S.C.) Upsala College (N.J.) University of South Carolina-Aiken (S.C.) Ursinus College (Pa.) University of South Carolina-Columbia Utah State University (Utah) (S.C.) Utica College (N.Y.) University of South Dakota (S.D.) Valdosta State University (Ga.) University of South Florida (Fla.) Valparaiso University (Ind.) University of Southern California (Calif.) Vanderbilt University (Tenn.) University of Southern Indiana (Ind.) Vassar College (N.Y.) University of Southern Maine (Maine) Villa Julie College (Md.) University of Southern Mississippi Villanova University (Pa.) (Miss.) Virginia Commonwealth University University of St Francis (Ill.) (Va.) University of St Thomas (Minn.) Virginia Military Institute (Va.) University of the District of Virginia Polytechnic Institute and Columbia (D.C.) State Univ (Va.) University of the Incarnate Word Virginia State University (Va.) (Tex.) Virginia Union University (Va.) University of the Ozarks (Ark.) Virginia Wesleyan College (Va.) University of the Pacific (Calif.) Wabash College (Ind.) University of the Sciences in Philadelphia (Pa.) Wagner College (N.Y.) University of Toledo (Ohio) Wake Forest University (N.C.) University of Tulsa (Okla.) Wartburg College (Iowa) University of Utah (Utah) Washburn University (Kan.) University of Vermont and State Washington & Jefferson College (Pa.) Agricultural Coll (Vt.) Washington and Lee University (Va.) University of Virginia-Main Campus (Va.) Washington College (Md.) University of Washington-Seattle Washington State University (Wash.) Campus (Wash.) Washington University in St Louis University of West Alabama (Ala.) (Mo.) University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire Wayne State College (Neb.) (Wis.) Wayne State University (Mich.) University of Wisconsin-Green Bay (Wis.) Waynesburg College (Pa.) University of Wisconsin-La Crosse Weber State University (Utah) (Wis.) Webster University (Mo.) University of Wisconsin-Madison (Wis.) Wellesley College (Mass.) University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee Wells College (N.Y.) (Wis.) Wentworth Institute of Technology University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh (Mass.) (Wis.) Wesley College (Del.) University of Wisconsin-Parkside (Wis.) Wesleyan College (Ga.) University of Wisconsin-Platteville Wesleyan University (Conn.) (Wis.) University of Wisconsin-River Falls (Wis.) University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point (Wis.) University of Wisconsin-Stout (Wis.) University of Wisconsin-Superior (Wis.) University of Wisconsin-Whitewater (Wis.) University of Wyoming (Wyo.) West Chester University of Wichita State University (Kan.) Pennsylvania (Pa.) Widener University-Main Campus (Pa.) West Liberty State College (W.Va.) Wiley College (Tex.) West Texas A & M University (Tex.) Wilkes University (Pa.) West Virginia State University (W.Va.) Willamette University (Ore.) West Virginia University (W.Va.) William Paterson University of New Jersey (N.J.) West Virginia University Institute of Technology (W.Va.) William Penn University (Iowa) West Virginia Wesleyan College Williams College (Mass.) (W.Va.) Wilmington College (Del.) Western Carolina University (N.C.) Wilmington College (Ohio) Western Connecticut State University (Conn.) Wilson College (Pa.) Western Illinois University (Ill.) Wingate University (N.C.) Western Kentucky University (Ky.) Winona State University (Minn.) Western Michigan University (Mich.) Winston-Salem State University (N.C.) Western New England College (Mass.) Winthrop University (S.C.) Western New Mexico University (N.M.) Wisconsin Lutheran College (Wis.) Western Oregon University (Ore.) Wittenberg University (Ohio) Western State College of Colorado (Colo.) Wofford College (S.C.) Western Washington University (Wash.) Worcester Polytechnic Institute (Mass.) Westfield State College (Mass.) Worcester State College (Mass.) Westminster College (Mo.) Wright State University-Main Campus Westminster College (Pa.) (Ohio) Wheaton College (Ill.) Xavier University (Ohio) Wheaton College (Mass.) Yale University (Conn.) Wheeling Jesuit University (W.Va.) Yeshiva University (N.Y.) Wheelock College (Mass.) York College Pennsylvania (Pa.) Whitman College (Wash.) Youngstown State University (Ohio) Whittier College (Calif.) Whitworth College (Wash.) Source: NCAA and Department of Education. Notes: For some schools, "A & M" no longer signifies "Agricultural and Mechanical" but is simply part of the school name School names are listed as they were reported to the Department of Education through the IPEDS system. Thus, some names may differ from how they are listed in the NCAA membership directories. Appendix IV: Schools Included in the Closed Group The following 750 schools were included in the closed group of NCAA members that met the following three criteria: o They were members of the NCAA in each year from 1991-1992 to 2004-2005. o They were not also members of the second-largest athletic association, the NAIA, in any year from 1991-1992 to 2004-2005. o They reported team and participant information consistently each year from 1991-1992 to 2004-2005. Table 4: Closed-Group Schools (state abbreviation) Abilene Christian University (Tex.) Augustana College (Ill.) Adelphi University (N.Y.) Augustana College (S.D.) Adrian College (Mich.) Aurora University (Ill.) Alabama A & M University (Ala.) Austin Peay State University (Tenn.) Alabama State University (Ala.) Averett University (Va.) Albany State University (Ga.) Babson College (Mass.) Albertus Magnus College (Conn.) Baldwin-Wallace College (Ohio) Albion College (Mich.) Ball State University (Ind.) Albright College (Pa.) Barnard College (N.Y.) Alcorn State University (Miss.) Barry University (Fla.) Alfred University (N.Y.) Bates College (Maine) Allegheny College (Pa.) Baylor University (Tex.) Alma College (Mich.) Bellarmine University (Ky.) American International College Beloit College (Wis.) (Mass.) Bemidji State University (Minn.) American University (D.C.) Benedictine University (Ill.) Angelo State University (Tex.) Bentley College (Mass.) Anna Maria College (Mass.) Bethany College (W.Va.) Appalachian State University (N.C.) Bethel University (Minn.) Arizona State University at the Tempe Campus (Ariz.) Bethune Cookman College (Fla.) Arkansas State University-Main Campus Blackburn College (Ill.) (Ark.) Bloomsburg University of Armstrong Atlantic State University Pennsylvania (Pa.) (Ga.) Bluffton University (Ohio) Ashland University (Ohio) Boise State University (Idaho) Assumption College (Mass.) Boston College (Mass.) Auburn University Main Campus (Ala.) Boston University (Mass.) Augsburg College (Minn.) Bowdoin College (Maine) Augusta State University (Ga.) Bowie State University (Md.) Campbell University Inc (N.C.) Bowling Green State University-Main Canisius College (N.Y.) Campus (Ohio) Capital University (Ohio) Bradley University (Ill.) Carleton College (Minn.) Brandeis University (Mass.) Carnegie Mellon University (Pa.) Bridgewater College (Va.) Carroll College (Wis.) Bridgewater State College (Mass.) Carthage College (Wis.) Brigham Young University (Utah) Case Western Reserve University Brown University (R.I.) (Ohio) Bryant University (R.I.) Catholic University of America (D.C.) Bryn Mawr College (Pa.) Centenary College of Louisiana (La.) Bucknell University (Pa.) Central College (Iowa) Buena Vista University (Iowa) Central Connecticut State University Cabrini College (Pa.) (Conn.) California Institute of Technology Central Michigan University (Mich.) (Calif.) Central Missouri State University California Lutheran University (Mo.) (Calif.) Centre College (Ky.) California Polytechnic State University-San Luis Obispo (Calif.) Chaminade University of Honolulu (Hawaii) California State Polytechnic University-Pomona (Calif.) Chapman University (Calif.) California State Charleston Southern University University-Bakersfield (Calif.) (S.C.) California State University-Chico Cheyney University of Pennsylvania (Calif.) (Pa.) California State University-Dominguez Christopher Newport University (Va.) Hills (Calif.) Citadel Military College of South California State University-Fresno Carolina (S.C.) (Calif.) Claremont Mckenna College (Calif.) California State University-Fullerton (Calif.) Clarion University of Pennsylvania (Pa.) California State University-Long Beach (Calif.) Clark Atlanta University (Ga.) California State University-Los Clark University (Mass.) Angeles (Calif.) Clarkson University (N.Y.) California State University-Northridge (Calif.) Clemson University (S.C.) California State Cleveland State University (Ohio) University-Sacramento (Calif.) Coastal Carolina University (S.C.) California State University-San Bernardino (Calif.) Coe College (Iowa) California State Colby College (Maine) University-Stanislaus (Calif.) Colby-Sawyer College (N.H.) California University of Pennsylvania (Pa.) Colgate University (N.Y.) Calvin College (Mich.) College of Charleston (S.C.) Cameron University (Okla.) College of Notre Dame of Maryland (Md.) College of Our Lady of the Elms (Mass.) College of Saint Benedict (Minn.) College of Saint Elizabeth (N.J.) Desales University (Pa.) College of St Catherine (Minn.) Dickinson College (Pa.) College of the Holy Cross (Mass.) Dowling College (N.Y.) College of William and Mary (Va.) Drake University (Iowa) College of Wooster (Ohio) Drew University (N.J.) Colorado Christian University (Colo.) Drexel University (Pa.) Colorado College (Colo.) Duke University (N.C.) Colorado State University (Colo.) Duquesne University (Pa.) Colorado State University-Pueblo Earlham College (Ind.) (Colo.) East Carolina University (N.C.) Columbus State University (Ga.) East Stroudsburg University of Concordia College (N.Y.) Pennsylvania (Pa.) Concordia College at Moorhead (Minn.) East Tennessee State University (Tenn.) Concordia University (Ill.) Eastern Connecticut State University Connecticut College (Conn.) (Conn.) Coppin State University (Md.) Eastern Illinois University (Ill.) Cornell College (Iowa) Eastern Kentucky University (Ky.) Cornell University-Endowed Colleges Eastern Mennonite University (Va.) (N.Y.) Eastern Michigan University (Mich.) Creighton University (Neb.) Eastern Nazarene College (Mass.) CUNY City College (N.Y.) Eastern New Mexico University-Main CUNY College of Staten Island (N.Y.) Campus (N.M.) CUNY Hunter College (N.Y.) Eastern Washington University (Wash.) CUNY John Jay College Criminal Justice (N.Y.) Eckerd College (Fla.) CUNY Lehman College (N.Y.) Edinboro University of Pennsylvania (Pa.) CUNY Medgar Evers College (N.Y.) Elizabeth City State University CUNY Queens College (N.Y.) (N.C.) CUNY York College (N.Y.) Elizabethtown College (Pa.) Curry College (Mass.) Elmhurst College (Ill.) Daniel Webster College (N.H.) Elmira College (N.Y.) Dartmouth College (N.H.) Emerson College (Mass.) Davidson College (N.C.) Emmanuel College (Mass.) Defiance College (Ohio) Emory and Henry College (Va.) Delaware State University (Del.) Emory University (Ga.) Delaware Valley College (Pa.) Fairfield University (Conn.) Delta State University (Miss.) Fairleigh Dickinson University-College at Florham (N.J.) Denison University (Ohio) Fairleigh Dickinson Depaul University (Ill.) University-Metropolitan Campus (N.J.) Depauw University (Ind.) Fayetteville State University (N.C.) Ferris State University (Mich.) Gustavus Adolphus College (Minn.) Ferrum College (Va.) Hamilton College (N.Y.) Fisk University (Tenn.) Hamline University (Minn.) Fitchburg State College (Mass.) Hampden-Sydney College (Va.) Florida Agricultural and Mechanical Hampton University (Va.) University (Fla.) Hartwick College (N.Y.) Florida Atlantic University-Boca Raton (Fla.) Harvard University (Mass.) Florida Institute of Haverford College (Pa.) Technology-Melbourne (Fla.) Heidelberg College (Ohio) Florida International University (Fla.) Hiram College (Ohio) Florida Southern College (Fla.) Hobart William Smith Colleges (N.Y.) Florida State University (Fla.) Hofstra University (N.Y.) Fontbonne University (Mo.) Hollins University (Va.) Fordham University (N.Y.) Hood College (Md.) Fort Valley State University (Ga.) Hope College (Mich.) Framingham State College (Mass.) Howard University (D.C.) Franklin and Marshall College (Pa.) Humboldt State University (Calif.) Franklin Pierce College (N.H.) Idaho State University (Idaho) Frostburg State University (Md.) Illinois College (Ill.) Furman University (S.C.) Illinois State University (Ill.) Gallaudet University (D.C.) Illinois Wesleyan University (Ill.) Gannon University (Pa.) Immaculata University (Pa.) George Mason University (Va.) Indiana State University (Ind.) George Washington University (D.C.) Indiana University of Pennsylvania-Main Campus (Pa.) Georgetown University (D.C.) Indiana University-Bloomington Georgia College and State University (Ind.) (Ga.) Indiana University-Purdue Georgia Institute of Technology-Main University-Fort Wayne (Ind.) Campus (Ga.) Iona College (N.Y.) Georgia Southern University (Ga.) Iowa State University (Iowa) Georgia State University (Ga.) Ithaca College (N.Y.) Gettysburg College (Pa.) Jackson State University (Miss.) Gonzaga University (Wash.) Jacksonville State University (Ala.) Goucher College (Md.) Jacksonville University (Fla.) Grambling State University (La.) James Madison University (Va.) Grand Valley State University (Mich.) John Carroll University (Ohio) Greensboro College (N.C.) Johns Hopkins University (Md.) Grinnell College (Iowa) Johnson C Smith University (N.C.) Grove City College (Pa.) Juniata College (Pa.) Guilford College (N.C.) Kalamazoo College (Mich.) Luther College (Iowa) Kansas State University (Kan.) Lycoming College (Pa.) Kean University (N.J.) Lynchburg College (Va.) Keene State College (N.H.) Macalester College (Minn.) Kent State University-Main Campus MacMurray College (Ill.) (Ohio) Manhattan College (N.Y.) Kentucky State University (Ky.) Manhattanville College (N.Y.) Kenyon College (Ohio) Mansfield University of Pennsylvania Keuka College (N.Y.) (Pa.) Kings College (Pa.) Marietta College (Ohio) Knox College (Ill.) Marist College (N.Y.) Kutztown University of Pennsylvania Marquette University (Wis.) (Pa.) Marshall University (W.Va.) La Salle University (Pa.) Mary Baldwin College (Va.) Lafayette College (Pa.) Marymount University (Va.) Lake Forest College (Ill.) Maryville College (Tenn.) Lake Superior State University (Mich.) Maryville University of Saint Louis (Mo.) Lamar University (Tex.) Marywood University (Pa.) Lander University (S.C.) Massachusetts College of Liberal Lawrence University (Wis.) Arts (Mass.) Le Moyne College (N.Y.) Massachusetts Institute of Technology (Mass.) Le Moyne-Owen College (Tenn.) Massachusetts Maritime Academy Lebanon Valley College (Pa.) (Mass.) Lewis University (Ill.) McDaniel College (Md.) Liberty University (Va.) McNeese State University (La.) Lincoln Memorial University (Tenn.) Mercer University (Ga.) Lincoln University (Mo.) Mercy College-Main Campus (N.Y.) Lincoln University (Pa.) Mercyhurst College (Pa.) Livingstone College (N.C.) Merrimack College (Mass.) Lock Haven University of Pennsylvania Messiah College (Pa.) (Pa.) Methodist College (N.C.) Long Island University-Brooklyn Campus (N.Y.) Metropolitan State College of Denver (Colo.) Long Island University-C W Post Campus (N.Y.) Miami University-Oxford (Ohio) Loras College (Iowa) Michigan State University (Mich.) Louisiana State Univ & Ag & Mech & Michigan Technological University Hebert Laws Ctr (La.) (Mich.) Louisiana Tech University (La.) Middle Tennessee State University (Tenn.) Loyola College in Maryland (Md.) Middlebury College (Vt.) Loyola Marymount University (Calif.) Miles College (Ala.) Loyola University Chicago (Ill.) Millersville University of Pennsylvania (Pa.) Millikin University (Ill.) North Carolina Wesleyan College (N.C.) Millsaps College (Miss.) North Central College (Ill.) Minnesota State University-Mankato (Minn.) North Dakota State University-Main Campus (N.D.) Mississippi College (Miss.) North Park University (Ill.) Mississippi State University (Miss.) Northeastern University (Mass.) Mississippi Valley State University (Miss.) Northern Arizona University (Ariz.) Missouri Southern State University Northern Illinois University (Ill.) (Mo.) Northern Kentucky University (Ky.) Molloy College (N.Y.) Northern Michigan University (Mich.) Monmouth College (Ill.) Northwestern State University of Monmouth University (N.J.) Louisiana (La.) Montana State University-Billings Northwestern University (Ill.) (Mont.) Norwich University (Vt.) Montana State University-Bozeman (Mont.) Oberlin College (Ohio) Montclair State University (N.J.) Occidental College (Calif.) Morehead State University (Ky.) Oglethorpe University (Ga.) Morehouse College (Ga.) Ohio Northern University (Ohio) Morgan State University (Md.) Ohio State University-Main Campus (Ohio) Mount Holyoke College (Mass.) Ohio University-Main Campus (Ohio) Mount Saint Mary College (N.Y.) Ohio Wesleyan University (Ohio) Mount St Mary's University (Md.) Oklahoma State University-Main Mount Union College (Ohio) Campus (Okla.) Muhlenberg College (Pa.) Old Dominion University (Va.) Murray State University (Ky.) Olivet College (Mich.) Muskingum College (Ohio) Oregon State University (Ore.) Nazareth College of Rochester (N.Y.) Otterbein College (Ohio) New England College (N.H.) Pace University-New York (N.Y.) New Jersey City University (N.J.) Paine College (Ga.) New Jersey Institute of Technology Pennsylvania State University-Main (N.J.) Campus (Pa.) New Mexico State University-Main Pennsylvania State Univ-Penn St Campus (N.M.) Erie-Behrend Coll (Pa.) New York University (N.Y.) Pepperdine University (Calif.) Niagara University (N.Y.) Philadelphia University (Pa.) Nicholls State University (La.) Pine Manor College (Mass.) Nichols College (Mass.) Pittsburg State University (Kan.) Norfolk State University (Va.) Pitzer College (Calif.) North Carolina A & T State University Plymouth State University (N.H.) (N.C.) Polytechnic University (N.Y.) North Carolina Central University (N.C.) North Carolina State University at Raleigh (N.C.) Portland State University (Ore.) Saint Leo University (Fla.) Princeton University (N.J.) Saint Louis University-Main Campus (Mo.) Principia College (Ill.) Saint Mary's College (Ind.) Providence College (R.I.) Saint Marys College of California Purdue University-Main Campus (Ind.) (Calif.) Queens University of Charlotte (N.C.) Saint Mary's University of Minnesota (Minn.) Quinnipiac University (Conn.) Saint Michaels College (Vt.) Radford University (Va.) Saint Norbert College (Wis.) Ramapo College of New Jersey (N.J.) Saint Pauls College (Va.) Randolph-Macon College (Va.) Saint Peters College (N.J.) Regis College (Mass.) Salem State College (Mass.) Regis University (Colo.) Salisbury University (Md.) Rhode Island College (R.I.) Salve Regina University (R.I.) Rhodes College (Tenn.) Sam Houston State University (Tex.) Rice University (Tex.) Samford University (Ala.) Rider University (N.J.) San Diego State University (Calif.) Ripon College (Wis.) San Francisco State University Roanoke College (Va.) (Calif.) Robert Morris University (Pa.) San Jose State University (Calif.) Rochester Institute of Technology Santa Clara University (Calif.) (N.Y.) Savannah State University (Ga.) Rockford College (Ill.) Seattle Pacific University (Wash.) Rollins College (Fla.) Seton Hall University (N.J.) Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology (Ind.) Sewanee: The University of the South (Tenn.) Rosemont College (Pa.) Shaw University (N.C.) Rowan University (N.J.) Shenandoah University (Va.) Rust College (Miss.) Shippensburg University of Rutgers University-Camden (N.J.) Pennsylvania (Pa.) Rutgers University-New Brunswick Siena College (N.Y.) (N.J.) Simmons College (Mass.) Rutgers University-Newark (N.J.) Simpson College (Iowa) Saginaw Valley State University (Mich.) Skidmore College (N.Y.) Saint Anselm College (N.H.) Slippery Rock University of Pennsylvania (Pa.) Saint Augustines College (N.C.) Smith College (Mass.) Saint Bonaventure University (N.Y.) Sonoma State University (Calif.) Saint Cloud State University (Minn.) South Carolina State University Saint Francis University (Pa.) (S.C.) Saint John Fisher College (N.Y.) South Dakota State University (S.D.) Saint Johns University (Minn.) Southeast Missouri State University (Mo.) Saint Josephs College (Ind.) Southeastern Louisiana University Saint Josephs University (Pa.) (La.) Southern Connecticut State University SUNY Maritime College (N.Y.) (Conn.) SUNY-Potsdam (N.Y.) Southern Illinois University Carbondale (Ill.) Susquehanna University (Pa.) Southern Illinois University Swarthmore College (Pa.) Edwardsville (Ill.) Sweet Briar College (Va.) Southern Methodist University (Tex.) Syracuse University (N.Y.) Southern New Hampshire University (N.H.) Temple University (Pa.) Southern University and A & M College Tennessee State University (Tenn.) (La.) Tennessee Technological University Southern Utah University (Utah) (Tenn.) Southwest Baptist University (Mo.) Texas A & M University (Tex.) Southwest Missouri State University Texas A & M University-Commerce (Mo.) (Tex.) Southwest Missouri State University Texas A & M University-Kingsville (Mo.) (Tex.) Springfield College (Mass.) Texas Christian University (Tex.) St Francis College (N.Y.) Texas State University-San Marcos (Tex.) St John's University-New York (N.Y.) Texas Tech University (Tex.) St Lawrence University (N.Y.) Texas Woman's University (Tex.) St Mary's College of Maryland (Md.) The College of New Jersey (N.J.) State University of West Georgia (Ga.) The College of New Rochelle (N.Y.) Stephen F Austin State University The College of Saint Rose (N.Y.) (Tex.) The Richard Stockton College of New Stetson University (Fla.) Jersey (N.J.) Stevens Institute of Technology The University of Alabama (Ala.) (N.J.) The University of Montana-Missoula Stonehill College (Mass.) (Mont.) Suffolk University (Mass.) The University of Tampa (Fla.) SUNY at Albany (N.Y.) The University of Tennessee (Tenn.) SUNY at Binghamton (N.Y.) The University of Tennessee-Chattanooga (Tenn.) SUNY at Buffalo (N.Y.) The University of Tennessee-Martin SUNY at Stony Brook (N.Y.) (Tenn.) SUNY College at Brockport (N.Y.) The University of Texas at Arlington (Tex.) SUNY College at Buffalo (N.Y.) The University of Texas at Austin SUNY College at Cortland (N.Y.) (Tex.) SUNY College at Fredonia (N.Y.) The University of Texas at El Paso (Tex.) SUNY College at Geneseo (N.Y.) The University of Texas at San SUNY College at New Paltz (N.Y.) Antonio (Tex.) SUNY College at Old Westbury (N.Y.) The University of Texas-Pan American (Tex.) SUNY College at Oneonta (N.Y.) Thiel College (Pa.) SUNY College at Oswego (N.Y.) Thomas More College (Ky.) SUNY College at Plattsburgh (N.Y.) Towson University (Md.) SUNY Institute of Technology at Utica-Rome (N.Y.) Trinity College (Conn.) University of Georgia (Ga.) Trinity University (Tex.) University of Hartford (Conn.) Troy State University-Main Campus University of Hawaii at Manoa (Ala.) (Hawaii) Truman State University (Mo.) University of Idaho (Idaho) Tufts University (Mass.) University of Illinois at Chicago (Ill.) Tuskegee University (Ala.) University of Illinois at Union College (N.Y.) Urbana-Champaign (Ill.) United States Air Force Academy University of Indianapolis (Ind.) (Colo.) University of Iowa (Iowa) United States Coast Guard Academy (Conn.) University of Kansas Main Campus (Kan.) United States Military Academy (N.Y.) University of Kentucky (Ky.) United States Naval Academy (Md.) University of La Verne (Calif.) University of Akron Main Campus (Ohio) University of Louisiana at Lafayette (La.) University of Alabama at Birmingham (Ala.) University of Louisiana at Monroe (La.) University of Alabama in Huntsville (Ala.) University of Louisville (Ky.) University of Alaska Anchorage University of Maine (Maine) (Alaska) University of Mary Washington (Va.) University of Alaska Fairbanks (Alaska) University of Maryland-Baltimore County (Md.) University of Arizona (Ariz.) University of Maryland-College Park University of Arkansas at Little Rock (Md.) (Ark.) University of Maryland-Eastern Shore University of Arkansas Main Campus (Md.) (Ark.) University of Massachusetts-Amherst University of Bridgeport (Conn.) (Mass.) University of California-Davis University of Massachusetts-Boston (Calif.) (Mass.) University of California-Irvine University of (Calif.) Massachusetts-Dartmouth (Mass.) University of California-Riverside University of Massachusetts-Lowell (Calif.) (Mass.) University of California-San Diego University of Memphis (Tenn.) (Calif.) University of Miami (Fla.) University of California-Santa Barbara (Calif.) University of Michigan-Ann Arbor (Mich.) University of Central Florida (Fla.) University of Minneasota-Twin Cities University of Central Oklahoma (Minn.) (Okla.) University of Mississippi Main University of Chicago (Ill.) Campus (Miss.) University of Cincinnati-Main Campus University of Missouri-Columbia (Ohio) (Mo.) University of Colorado at Boulder University of Missouri-Kansas City (Colo.) (Mo.) University of Dayton (Ohio) University of Missouri-Rolla (Mo.) University of Delaware (Del.) University of Missouri-St Louis (Mo.) University of Denver (Colo.) University of Nebraska at Kearney University of Detroit Mercy (Mich.) (Neb.) University of Dubuque (Iowa) University of Nebraska at Lincoln (Neb.) University of Evansville (Ind.) University of Florida (Fla.) University of Nebraska at Omaha University of South Carolina Upstate (Neb.) (S.C.) University of Nevada-Las Vegas (Nev.) University of South Carolina-Aiken (S.C.) University of Nevada-Reno (Nev.) University of South University of New Hampshire-Main Carolina-Columbia (S.C.) Campus (N.H.) University of South Dakota (S.D.) University of New Haven (Conn.) University of South Florida (Fla.) University of New Mexico-Main Campus (N.M.) University of Southern California (Calif.) University of New Orleans (La.) University of Southern Indiana University of North Alabama (Ala.) (Ind.) University of North Carolina at University of Southern Maine (Maine) Asheville (N.C.) University of Southern Mississippi University of North Carolina at (Miss.) Chapel Hill (N.C.) University of St Thomas (Minn.) University of North Carolina at Charlotte (N.C.) University of the District of Columbia (D.C.) University of North Carolina at Greensboro (N.C.) University of the Pacific (Calif.) University of North Carolina at University of Toledo (Ohio) Pembroke (N.C.) University of Tulsa (Okla.) University of North Carolina-Wilmington (N.C.) University of Utah (Utah) University of North Dakota-Main University of Vermont and State Campus (N.D.) Agricultural Coll (Vt.) University of North Texas (Tex.) University of Virginia-Main Campus (Va.) University of Northern Colorado (Colo.) University of Washington-Seattle Campus (Wash.) University of Northern Iowa (Iowa) University of West Alabama (Ala.) University of Notre Dame (Ind.) University of Wisconsin-Green Bay University of Oklahoma Norman Campus (Wis.) (Okla.) University of Wisconsin-La Crosse University of Oregon (Ore.) (Wis.) University of Pennsylvania (Pa.) University of Wisconsin-Madison (Wis.) University of Pittsburgh-Main Campus (Pa.) University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee (Wis.) University of Portland (Ore.) University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh University of Redlands (Calif.) (Wis.) University of Rhode Island (R.I.) University of Wisconsin-Stout (Wis.) University of Richmond (Va.) University of Wisconsin-Superior (Wis.) University of Rochester (N.Y.) University of Wisconsin-Whitewater University of San Diego (Calif.) (Wis.) University of San Francisco (Calif.) University of Wyoming (Wyo.) University of Scranton (Pa.) Upper Iowa University (Iowa) University of South Alabama (Ala.) Ursinus College (Pa.) Utah State University (Utah) Utica College (N.Y.) Valdosta State University (Ga.) Valparaiso University (Ind.) Vanderbilt University (Tenn.) Vassar College (N.Y.) Villanova University (Pa.) Virginia Commonwealth University Western Carolina University (N.C.) (Va.) Western Connecticut State University Virginia Military Institute (Va.) (Conn.) Virginia Polytechnic Institute and Western Illinois University (Ill.) State Univ (Va.) Western Kentucky University (Ky.) Virginia State University (Va.) Western Michigan University (Mich.) Virginia Union University (Va.) Western New England College (Mass.) Virginia Wesleyan College (Va.) Westfield State College (Mass.) Wabash College (Ind.) Wheaton College (Ill.) Wagner College (N.Y.) Wheaton College (Mass.) Wake Forest University (N.C.) Whittier College (Calif.) Wartburg College (Iowa) Wichita State University (Kan.) Washburn University (Kan.) Widener University-Main Campus (Pa.) Washington & Jefferson College (Pa.) Wilkes University (Pa.) Washington and Lee University (Va.) William Paterson University of New Washington College (Md.) Jersey (N.J.) Washington State University (Wash.) Williams College (Mass.) Washington University in St Louis Wilmington College (Del.) (Mo.) Winston-Salem State University Wayne State College (Neb.) (N.C.) Wayne State University (Mich.) Winthrop University (S.C.) Waynesburg College (Pa.) Wittenberg University (Ohio) Weber State University (Utah) Wofford College (S.C.) Webster University (Mo.) Worcester Polytechnic Institute (Mass.) Wellesley College (Mass.) Worcester State College (Mass.) Wells College (N.Y.) Wright State University-Main Campus Wentworth Institute of Technology (Ohio) (Mass.) Xavier University (Ohio) Wesley College (Del.) Yale University (Conn.) Wesleyan University (Conn.) Yeshiva University (N.Y.) West Chester University of Pennsylvania (Pa.) York College Pennsylvania (Pa.) West Texas A & M University (Tex.) Youngstown State University (Ohio) West Virginia University (W.Va.) Sources: NCAA and Department of Education. Notes: For some schools, "A & M" no longer signifies "Agricultural and Mechanical" but is simply part of the school name. School names are listed as they were reported to the Department of Education through the IPEDS system. Thus, some names may differ from how they are listed in the NCAA membership directories. Appendix V: Comments from the Department of Education Appendix VI: GAO Contact and Staff Acknowledgments GAO Contact George A. Scott, Director, (202) 512-7215, [21][email protected] . Staff Acknowledgments Melissa Emrey-Arras, Assistant Director, and Jeffrey W. Weinstein, Analyst-in-Charge, managed this assignment. Other staff members who made key contributions throughout the assignment include Cornelia Ashby, Jeff Appel, Claudine Pauselli, Ann-Marie Udale, Rachael Valliere, and Carla Craddock. Luann Moy assisted with methodology and data reliability testing. Sheila McCoy provided legal assistance. Lisa Mirel, Alice Feldesman, Karen Burke, and Avy Ashery provided assistance with graphics and layout. Related GAO Products Intercollegiate Athletics: Trends by Sport in National Collegiate Athletic Association Sports. [22]GAO-07-744SP . Washington, D.C.: July 12, 2007. Intercollegiate Athletics: Four-Year Colleges' Experiences Adding and Discontinuing Teams. [23]GAO-01-297 . Washington, D.C.: March 8, 2001. Gender Equity: Men's and Women's Participation in Higher Education. [24]GAO-01-128 . Washington, D.C.: December 15, 2000. Intercollegiate Athletics: Comparison of Selected Characteristics for Men's and Women's Programs. [25]HEHS-99-3R . Washington, D.C.: June 18, 1999. Intercollegiate Athletics: Status of Efforts to Promote Gender Equity. [26]HEHS-97-10 . Washington, D.C.: October 25, 1996. Intercollegiate Athletics: Compensation Varies for Selected Personnel in Athletic Departments. [27]HRD-92-121 . Washington, D.C.: August 19, 1992. (130543) GAO's Mission The Government Accountability Office, the audit, evaluation and investigative arm of Congress, exists to support Congress in meeting its constitutional responsibilities and to help improve the performance and accountability of the federal government for the American people. GAO examines the use of public funds; evaluates federal programs and policies; and provides analyses, recommendations, and other assistance to help Congress make informed oversight, policy, and funding decisions. GAO's commitment to good government is reflected in its core values of accountability, integrity, and reliability. Obtaining Copies of GAO Reports and Testimony The fastest and easiest way to obtain copies of GAO documents at no cost is through GAO's Web site ( [28]www.gao.gov ). Each weekday, GAO posts newly released reports, testimony, and correspondence on its Web site. To have GAO e-mail you a list of newly posted products every afternoon, go to [29]www.gao.gov and select "Subscribe to Updates." Order by Mail or Phone The first copy of each printed report is free. Additional copies are $2 each. A check or money order should be made out to the Superintendent of Documents. GAO also accepts VISA and Mastercard. Orders for 100 or more copies mailed to a single address are discounted 25 percent. Orders should be sent to: U.S. Government Accountability Office 441 G Street NW, Room LM Washington, D.C. 20548 To order by Phone: Voice: (202) 512-6000 TDD: (202) 512-2537 Fax: (202) 512-6061 To Report Fraud, Waste, and Abuse in Federal Programs Contact: Web site: [30]www.gao.gov/fraudnet/fraudnet.htm E-mail: [31][email protected] Automated answering system: (800) 424-5454 or (202) 512-7470 Congressional Relations Gloria Jarmon, Managing Director, [32][email protected] (202) 512-4400 U.S. Government Accountability Office, 441 G Street NW, Room 7125 Washington, D.C. 20548 Public Affairs Paul Anderson, Managing Director, [33][email protected] (202) 512-4800 U.S. Government Accountability Office, 441 G Street NW, Room 7149 Washington, D.C. 20548 [34]www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-07-535 . To view the full product, including the scope and methodology, click on the link above. To view the e-supplement online, click on www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt? [35]GAO-07-744SP . For more information, contact George A. Scott at (202) 512-7215 or [email protected]. Highlights of [36]GAO-07-535 , a report to congressional addressees July 2007 INTERCOLLEGIATE ATHLETICS Recent Trends in Teams and Participants in National Collegiate Athletic Association Sports Since the 1970s, the roles of women as both students and athletes have changed in higher education, with female enrollment surpassing male enrollment, and female athletic participation showing gains as well. These changes have generated public interest in whether women participate in athletics at comparable levels to men and whether men's opportunities have decreased as a result of the increased opportunities for women. Under the Comptroller General's authority, GAO assessed the extent to which the numbers of men's and women's intercollegiate sports teams and participants at 4-year colleges have changed from the 1991-1992 through 2004-2005 school years. To address these issues, GAO analyzed athletic data from the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) for two groups of colleges: (a) the entire NCAA membership, or open group, for which trends will reflect school-level decisions and membership changes, and (b) the consistent members of the NCAA throughout this period, or closed group, for which trends will reflect school-level decisions only. We used NCAA data because they were the only viable option for analyzing annual athletic trends for teams and participants over an extended period. We analyzed those sports for which team and participant data were reported each year for both groups of colleges. While the numbers of both men's and women's intercollegiate sports teams increased from 1991-1992 to 2004-2005, women's teams showed greater gains than men's teams. In fact, there have been more women's than men's teams since the mid-to-late 1990s for both the entire NCAA membership and the group of colleges that were consistent members of the NCAA throughout this period. For both groups of schools, most women's sports and some men's sports showed increases in teams, but many men's sports showed mixed or small changes in the number of teams. The numbers of both male and female athletic participants increased from 1991-1992 to 2004-2005--with female participants showing larger rates of increase--but men's participation levels were greater than women's throughout this time period, both in absolute terms and relative to their respective enrollments. Most women's sports and half of men's sports showed increases in the number of participants across both groups of schools. In the context of enrollment, female participation grew at a faster rate than female enrollment in both groups of schools. However, from 1991-1992 to 2004-2005, overall participation rates were significantly greater for men in at least three out of four coed schools in the closed group. Number of Male and Female Participants in the Open and Closed Groups, 1991-1992 to 2004-2005 School Years Notes: These counts reflect the sum of the participants in each of the individual sports that were consistently reported throughout the time period. To the extent that athletes participated on more than one team, the number of participants may be overstated. For the open group, counts for 1995-1996 through 2004-2005 include colleges that had applied for but not yet been given full NCAA membership status; counts for 1991-1992 through 1994-1995 do not include such colleges. Open-group participant counts for 1995-1996 through 1998-1999 are NCAA estimates based on athletic records collected by schools to meet the requirements of the Equity in Athletics Disclosure Act. References Visible links 13. ://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-07-744SP 14. http://www.gao.gov/ 15. mailto:[email protected] 16. http://www2.ncaa.org/portal/media_and_events/ncaa_publications/research 17. http://nces.ed.gov/ipedspas 18. http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-01-297 19. http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-07-744SP 20. http://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2005175 21. mailto:[email protected] 22. http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-07-744SP 23. http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-01-297 24. http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-01-128 25. http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?HEHS-99-3R 26. http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?HEHS-97-10 27. http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?HRD-92-121 28. http://www.gao.gov/ 29. http://www.gao.gov/ 30. http://www.gao.gov/fraudnet/fraudnet.htm 31. mailto:[email protected] 32. mailto:[email protected] 33. mailto:[email protected] 34. http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-07-535 35. http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-07-744SP 36. http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO-07-535 *** End of document. ***